A newsletter, or a recipe website?
Substack is built around publishing to an inbox and finding readers through its network. Crumb is built around recipes people can find, print and cook from. Both can send emails and sell memberships.
Crumb is our product, so weigh that. Everything about Substack comes from its own pricing and help pages, checked October 18, 2026, and is linked at the bottom.
Substack and Crumb, side by side
Substack has recipe embeds too. The differences are the cooking tools, the archive and the network around them.
✓ Supported · ✕ Not available · — Needs an add-on, has limits, or isn’t confirmed. Notes explain the difference.
| Feature | Substack | Crumb |
|---|---|---|
| Publishing cost | Free | $15 USD/month after 30 days public free for new direct signups. Build and preview free. |
| Recipe cards & recipe markup | Supported. Recipe embeds, currently in beta | Supported. Included |
| Recipe print view | Conditional or unconfirmed. Not documented in its recipe help | Supported. Included |
| Adjustable servings | Conditional or unconfirmed. Not documented in its recipe help | Supported. Included |
| Email subscribers | Supported. Included | Supported. Included |
| Paid memberships | Supported. Included | Supported. Included |
| Membership fee | 10% + Stripe fees. iOS purchases have separate Apple fees. | 8% + Stripe fees |
| Built-in discovery network | Supported. App, Notes and recommendations | Not available. Not available |
| Podcasts & community chat | Supported. Included | Not available. Not available |
| Instagram recipe import | Not available. No built-in import | Conditional or unconfirmed. Creator or Business accounts; limited rollout. Paste recipes anytime. |
| Custom domain connection | Supported. One-time $50 fee; domain purchased separately | Supported. Included; domain purchased separately |
| Export your recipes/posts | Supported. HTML and CSV export | Not available. Subscriber CSV only; no recipe or photo export yet |
Choose Substack if
- The newsletter is your main product.
- You want Substack’s discovery and community tools.
- You want to publish free, with no monthly bill.
Choose Crumb if
- Recipes are your main product.
- Readers want printing, scaling and a recipe archive.
- You want to turn Instagram captions into recipe drafts.
Which costs less?
With no paid members, Substack is free and Crumb is $15 a month. At $500 a month in membership revenue, Substack’s platform fee is $50; Crumb’s is $40 plus the $15 plan, or $55. The platform fees meet at $750 a month. Above that, Crumb’s are lower. Payment-processing fees are additional, and Substack’s iOS purchases have different economics.
You can use Substack for your newsletter and link to a Crumb recipe website. That keeps Substack’s discovery, but means managing two publishing tools.
Try it before you decide
Put one real recipe on Crumb and compare
Building and previewing is free, with no card. New creators who sign up directly get 30 days of public hosting free, then it’s $15 USD/month.
Build your website free