Keep Instagram. Do you need a website too?

Instagram helps people discover you. A recipe website gives them somewhere to cook from. If captions already do everything you need, there’s no rush to add a monthly bill.

Crumb is our product, so weigh that. Everything about Instagram comes from its own pricing and help pages, checked October 18, 2026, and is linked at the bottom.

Instagram and Crumb, side by side

These work together. The question is what a recipe website adds to your Instagram account.

✓ Supported · ✕ Not available · — Needs an add-on, has limits, or isn’t confirmed. Notes explain the difference.

FeatureInstagramCrumb
Publishing costFree$15 USD/month after 30 days public free for new direct signups. Build and preview free.
Built-in discovery feed
Supported. Reels, Explore and recommendations
Not available. Not available
Comments & DMs
Supported. Included
Not available. Not available
Dedicated recipe cards
Not available. Recipes live in captions or videos
Supported. Included
Recipe print view
Not available. Not available
Supported. Included
Adjustable servings
Not available. Not available
Supported. Included
Recipe markup for Google
Not available. Public professional posts can still appear in ordinary search results
Supported. Eligibility isn’t a guarantee of recipe results
Collect email subscribers
Not available. Link to an external signup tool
Supported. Included
Export your email list
Not available. Following an account is not an email subscription
Supported. CSV export
Paid memberships
Conditional or unconfirmed. Eligibility rules, including 10,000 followers
Supported. No follower minimum; Stripe setup required
Custom domain
Not available. Your profile lives on Instagram
Supported. Domain purchased separately
Hosting & software maintained
Supported. Included
Supported. Included

Choose Instagram if

  • You’re still finding your audience.
  • Captions cover what readers need.
  • You don’t want another monthly cost.

Choose Crumb if

  • Readers keep asking for printable recipes.
  • Older recipes are hard to find on your grid.
  • You want an email list and paid memberships.

Use each for what it does well

Keep posting on Instagram so people can discover you. Link to a permanent recipe page when they want to cook. That page can include the full ingredients and method, a print view and serving scaling.

Crumb can turn full recipe captions into drafts through a connected Creator or Business account. Sync is rolling out gradually; pasting recipes works for everyone. A website still needs promotion—it doesn’t bring Instagram’s discovery with it.

Try it before you decide

Put one real recipe on Crumb and compare

Building and previewing is free, with no card. New creators who sign up directly get 30 days of public hosting free, then it’s $15 USD/month.

Build your website free

Other comparisons